Why Insurers are replacing IVRs with Voice AI

Interactive Voice Response (IVR) systems had their moment. They helped insurers deflect calls, route customers to the right department, and automate basic requests but policyholders stuck saying “representative” into the phone, the experience often felt like a dead-end. That’s why many insurance providers are now moving away from traditional IVR and leaning into conversational voice AI.

Voice AI doesn’t just answer calls. It holds real conversations. It listens, learns, remembers, and adapts in real time. More importantly, it meets customers where they are with expectations shaped by the likes of Siri, Alexa, and ChatGPT.

So what’s driving the shift? And what makes conversational voice AI a better fit for today’s insurance customer?

The problem with IVR

Let’s be honest, most IVR systems are clunky. They rely on rigid menus and keyword detection, which can frustrate users when requests don’t fit a pre-set script. Customers are bounced between options, often repeating themselves. And while IVR can handle high call volumes, it lacks empathy, personalization, and the ability to solve complex issues without human escalation.

Here’s what insurers are struggling with:

• Poor call containment: Customers frequently opt out or get stuck
• Limited context: IVRs don’t remember past conversations or pick up on tone
• Siloed systems: IVRs often don’t connect well with CRMs or policy data
• Static experience: There’s no personalization, no learning, no evolution

What conversational voice AI does differently

Voice AI offers a more flexible, human-like interaction. Instead of choosing from a list of options, customers can just speak naturally. The AI understands intent, processes requests in real time, and integrates directly with back-end systems to take action—no hold music required.

Here's what conversational AI brings to the table:

• 24/7 availability: Always on, without staffing overhead
• Real-time CRM integration: Pull up policy details or claim history instantly
• Personalization: Remembers past interactions to avoid repeat questions
• Sentiment analysis: Adjust tone or escalate when frustration is detected
• Omnichannel support: Send follow-up via SMS or escalate to live chat as needed

Telnyx Voice AI brings this experience to life with features like a direct integration with CRMs and policy databases, memory functionality to avoid repeat questions and easy AI Assistant Builder for voice and SMS. Insurers can design, test, and deploy AI-powered assistants with full control over tone, behavior, and memory.

Real-world insurance use cases

Insurers are already using voice AI to automate high-volume, low-complexity tasks while keeping the customer experience front and center. Here are some of the most common applications:

1. First notice of loss (FNOL) Customers can report incidents like accidents or property damage in natural language. Voice AI collects the details, checks for coverage, and initiates a claim immediately. Accenture notes this dramatically improves processing speed and customer satisfaction.

2. Claim status updates Instead of logging into a portal, customers can just ask, “what’s the status of my claim?” voice AI checks the CRM and responds with real-time information.

3. Policy information and servicing Need to check your deductible or coverage dates? Voice AI handles routine policy queries like without a live agent.

4. Billing and payment questions Customers can confirm payment due dates, update billing info, or make payments through voice all securely and efficiently.

5. Lead capture and qualification For inbound sales calls, voice AI can screen for eligibility, collect basic info, and route qualified leads to agents for follow-up. All while logging insights into your CRM.

Why insurers are making the switch

The business case for voice AI goes beyond better CX. It’s also about efficiency and scale.

• Lower call center volume: Accenture estimates insurers can cut contact center inquiries by up to 20%, saving millions annually.
• 24/7 coverage: Voice AI works round-the-clock, so insurers can meet expectations for instant answers.
• Faster resolution: Natural language processing eliminates the back-and-forth of button-pressing and escalations.
• Better retention: Gartner found that 38% of execs are investing in generative AI specifically to improve customer retention.

Telnyx amplifies these benefits with carrier-grade voice infrastructure and built-in GPU performance, giving insurers faster processing and real-time capabilities without juggling multiple vendors.

By using real-time data, remembering context, and adapting to tone, Telnyx Voice AI offers faster, smarter, more human interactions. From FNOL to policy questions, it’s already proving its value in insurance.

The bottom line?

IVRs helped insurance providers manage call traffic. But they weren’t built to meet today’s customer expectations. Voice AI is.When done right, conversational AI doesn’t just replace IVR. It delivers a whole new level of service.

Insurers who make the move now aren’t just improving customer experience, they’re setting themselves up for smarter operations and scalable growth.